Free Shipping over $25   •   Open 7 Days   •   Historic Downtown Bethlehem

Under $5

Filter by
Sort by Date, new to old
Sort by

275 products

Silver Paris keychain with Eiffel Tower, camera and airplane charms
Quick buy
Silver Paris Eiffel Tower Camera & Plane Keychain
New
$3.99
Set of 2 black rope bracelets with yellow sunflower charms on gift card
Quick buy
Black Rope Bracelet Set of 2 with Yellow Sunflower Charms
New
$4.99
Mushroom Cat Enamel Brooch Pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Mushroom Cat Enamel Brooch Pin
New
$4.99
Tulip flower pendant necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Tulip Flower Necklace | Gold or Silver
New
From $4.95
Y2K Plush Floppy Ear Bunny Keychain at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Y2K Plush Floppy Ear Bunny Keychain
New
$4.99
+ 1 more
Gold bow top earrings with wine red tulip drops
Quick buy
Gold Bow Top Wine Red Tulip Drop Earrings
New
$4.99
Embroidered Cat & Dog Ribbed Crew Socks | 5 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Embroidered Cat & Dog Ribbed Crew Socks | 5 Styles
New
$4.99
+ 2 more
White repeating penguin face print crew socks
Quick buy
White Repeating Penguin Face Print Crew Socks
New
$4.99
Cat Hair Clip | 3 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Cat Hair Clip | 3 Colors
New
$2.99
Yellow baby duck keychains with orange feet and beaks
Quick buy
Yellow Baby Duck Keychain
New
$3.99
Hanging Enamel Cat Dangle Earrings | 4 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Hanging Enamel Cat Dangle Earrings | 4 Colors
New
$4.99
+ 1 more
Red sparkly heart keychain with red cherry charms and gold ring
Quick buy
Red Sparkly Heart & Cherry Charm Keychain with Gold Ring
New
$3.99
Yin Yang Hugging Cats Enamel Brooch Pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Yin Yang Hugging Cats Enamel Brooch Pin
New
$4.99
Gold pastel mosaic heart stud earrings
Quick buy
Gold Pastel Mosaic Heart Stud Earrings
New
$4.99
Silver open ring with red stone worn on finger
Quick buy
Silver Open Ring with Red Stone
New
$4.99
Silver ornate band ring with light blue oval stone worn on finger
Quick buy
Silver Ornate Band Ring with Light Blue Stone
New
$4.99
Silver Star of Bethlehem three star open ring with rhinestone worn on finger
Quick buy
Silver Star of Bethlehem Three Star Open Ring with Rhinestone
New
$4.99
Silver blue crystal ball ornate band ring worn on hand
Quick buy
Silver Blue Crystal Ball Ornate Band Ring
New
$4.99
Red square retro white heart stud earrings
Quick buy
Red Square Retro White Heart Stud Earrings
New
$4.99
Red puffy fabric heart earrings with gold tone outline at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Puffy Fabric Heart Earrings with Gold Tone Outline
New
$4.99
Gold four leaf clover pendant necklace on Make A Wish card
Quick buy
Gold Four Leaf Clover Pendant Necklace on Make A Wish Card
New
$4.99
Silver interlocking fish dainty band ring on white background
Quick buy
Silver Interlocking Fish Dainty Band Ring
New
$4.99
Four-Leaf Clover Stud Earrings | Gold or Silver at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Four-Leaf Clover Stud Earrings | Gold or Silver
New
$4.99
Silver art deco ring with black enamel square and faux pearl flower at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Silver Art Deco Faux Pearl Flower Ring
New
$4.99
Gold square cut red gem thin band ring worn on hand
Quick buy
Gold Square Cut Red Gem Thin Band Ring
New
$4.99
Green enamel four leaf clover pin
Quick buy
Green Four Leaf Clover Enamel Pin
New
$4.99
Silver floral cross Faith open wrap ring on white background
Quick buy
Silver Floral Cross Faith Open Wrap Ring
New
$4.99
Triple Flower Claw Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Triple Flower Claw Hair Clip
New
$4.99
+ 3 more
Plumeria Flower Claw Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Plumeria Flower Claw Hair Clip
New
$3.99
+ 3 more
Minimalist Open Water Droplet Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Minimalist Open Water Droplet Ring
New
$4.99
Silver White Oversize Four Leaf Clover Earrings
Quick buy
Silver White Oversize Four Leaf Clover Earrings
New
$4.95
Gold Tone Geometric Reindeer Brooch Pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Gold Tone Geometric Reindeer Brooch Pin
New
$3.99
Cream cameo brooch pin with lady profile at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Vintage Style Cameo Brooch Pin
New
From $4.99
Gold and red candy cane dangle earrings
Quick buy
Gold and Red Candy Cane Dangle Earrings
New
$4.99
Green Christmas wreath brooch pin with red bow
Quick buy
Green Christmas Wreath with Red Bow Brooch Pin
New
$4.99
Green alien hugging cat enamel pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Green Alien Enamel Pin
New
$4.99
+ 1 more
Flying saucer cat abduction enamel pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Green Alien Cat Abduction Enamel Pin
New
$4.99
+ 1 more
Quick buy
Squiggle Line Hair Clip | 2 Colors
New
$4.99
Matte Rectangle Claw Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Matte Rectangle Claw Hair Clip
New
$3.99
+ 5 more
Black fabric and pearl coquette claw clip worn in a half-up bun
Quick buy
Black Fabric & Pearl Coquette Claw Clip
New
$4.99
Oversized Claw Hair Clip with Bow Accent at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Oversized Claw Hair Clip with Bow Accent
New
$2.99
Black firework burst punk bandana
Quick buy
Black Firework Burst Punk Bandana
New
$2.99
Open Knot Heart Adjustable Ring Minimalist Fashion Jewelry | 3 Options at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Open Knot Heart Adjustable Ring Minimalist Fashion Jewelry | 3 Options
New
$4.95
Y2K Cutout Star Link Bracelet | Gold or Silver at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Y2K Cutout Star Link Bracelet | Gold or Silver
New
$4.99
Cat Face Earrings with Rhinestone Eyes at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Cat Face Earrings with Rhinestone Eyes
New
$4.99
White Good Days On My Mind motel keychain with silver ring
Quick buy
White Good Days On My Mind Motel Keychain with Silver Ring
New
$4.99
Y2K Gummy Bear Hair Clips | Single or Set of 4 at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Y2K Gummy Bear Hair Clips | Single or Set of 4
New
From $1.50
Metallic Pink Hoop Earrings at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Metallic Pink Hoop Earrings | 2 Colors
New
$3.95

Trendy new jewelry, hair clips and charms for $5 or less. Mix & Match: buy 3 save 33%, buy 5 half off.