Best Sellers | The Attic Bethlehem

Thick Chain Link Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem

Quick buy

Thick Chain Link Necklace | Gold or Silver

New

From $4.95

Quick buy

See Through Butterfly Black Snap Clip Barrette

New

$0.99

+ 2 more

Quick buy

Y2K Sculpted Irregular Resin Bangle Bracelet | 9 Colors

New

$5.99

+ 5 more

Quick buy

Retro Three Daisy Hair Barrette

New

$1.99

+ 1 more

Quick buy

Christmas Santa and Reindeer Crew Socks

New

$6.99

+ 2 more

Quick buy

Green Embroidered Floral Ankle Socks

$5.95

+ 2 more

Blue square half frame sunglasses at The Attic Bethlehem

Quick buy

Square Half Frame Sunglasses | 4 Colors

New

From $11.95

+ 1 more

Quick buy

Embroidered Swirl Ankle Socks | 5 Colors

New

$5.95

+ 2 more

Quick buy

Troll Doll Earrings | 4 Options

New

From $7.95

+ 1 more

Quick buy

Tiny Flower Snap Hair Clip

New

$0.99

+ 3 more

Black vintage sewing machine drop earrings at The Attic Bethlehem

Quick buy

Black Vintage Sewing Machine & Rotary Phone Drop Earrings

New

$6.99

Quick buy

The Attic In-Store Gift Card

From $25.00

Quick buy

Matte Rectangle Claw Hair Clip

New

$3.99

+ 5 more

Quick buy

Silver Oversized Number Stretch Watch Ring

New

$10.99

+ 7 more

Quick buy

Ruffled Top Socks with a Nylon Bow

From $7.95

+ 1 more

Quick buy

Extra Wide Metal Choker Necklace | 3 Color Choices

From $9.95

Quick buy

Embroidered Brocade Socks

$6.99

+ 2 more

Quick buy

Small Floral Tube Socks

$6.95

+ 1 more

Quick buy

Filigree Heart Locket Pendant Necklace | Gold or Silver

New

$6.95

Quick buy

Silver Star and Crescent Moon Layered Necklace

New

$5.95

Quick buy

Gold 5 Butterflies Anklet

$4.95

Quick buy

Gold Tone Zodiac Constellation Pendant Necklace on Card | 12 Styles

New

$6.95

+ 9 more

Quick buy

Celestial Sun Moon Asymmetrical Huggie Earrings | 3 Colors

New

From $4.95

Quick buy

Rubber Duck Dangle Earrings | 5 Colors

New

From $4.95

+ 2 more

Quick buy

Copper Teal Sparkly Two Panel Boho Drop Earrings

New

$5.99

Quick buy

Gold Bow Stud Earrings with Faux Pearl Tails

New

$5.95

Quick buy

Oversized Shiny Heart Outline Claw Hair Clip

New

$4.99

Quick buy

Coquette Polka Dot Rubber Hair Barrette

New

$1.99

+ 3 more

Quick buy

Red Rose Earrings with Black Thread Bow Dangle

New

$5.99

Quick buy

Virgin Mary Medal & Cross Charm Rosary Bracelet | Gold or Silver

New

$5.99

Quick buy

Triple Moon Gemstone Pendant Necklace | 3 Colors

New

$6.99

Quick buy

Seasons Greetings Red Jingle Bell Earrings

$5.99

Quick buy

Silver Love Letter Envelope Dangle Earrings with Red Heart

New

$5.99

Quick buy

Cat Hair Clip | 3 Colors

New

$2.99

Quick buy

Silver Infinity Heart Rhinestone Pendant Necklace

New

$6.99

Black round full frame sunglasses with thin arms at The Attic Bethlehem

Quick buy

Round Full Frame Sunglasses with Thin Arms | 4 Colors

New

From $10.99

+ 1 more

Quick buy

Santa Hat Cat Earrings

$5.95

Quick buy

Green Lens Sunglasses

$11.95

Antique Style Watch Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem

Quick buy

Bronze Engraved Cover Pocket Watch Necklace

New

$17.99

Quick buy

Electric Guitar Keychain Bag Charm | 4 Colors

New

From $3.95

+ 1 more

Quick buy

14K Gold Gold Cubic Zirconia Earrings | Gold or Silver

$10.95

Quick buy

Red Soda Pop Glass Bottle Dangle Earrings on Silver Hooks

New

$5.99

Quick buy

Silver Large Flower Pendant Necklace on Cord with Beads

New

$8.99

Quick buy

Silver Large Cross Necklace with Small Crosses and Flowers

New

$8.95

Quick buy

Flowers and Dragonfly Ring

New

$5.95

Quick buy

Gold White Enamel Daisy Drop Earrings

New

$4.95

Quick buy

Purple Twisted Oil Drip Open Hoop Earrings

New

$5.99

Quick buy

.925 Sterling Silver Plated Star of Bethlehem Cuff Bracelet

$17.95