Free Shipping over $25   •   Open 7 Days   •   Historic Downtown Bethlehem

Star of Bethlehem Gifts

Filter by
Sort by Best Selling
Sort by

40 products

Quick buy
.925 Sterling Silver Plated Star of Bethlehem Cuff Bracelet
$17.95
18K Gold Plated Four Point Starburst Pendant Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Four Point Starburst Pendant Necklace
New
$10.99
Star of Bethlehem Shooting Star Adjustable Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Shooting Star Adjustable Ring
New
$4.99
18K Gold Plated Layered Celestial Starburst Pendant Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Layered Celestial Starburst Pendant Necklace
New
$18.99
Minimalist Celestial Four Point Star Pendant Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Minimalist Celestial Four Point Star Pendant Necklace
New
$6.99
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Drop Chain Earrings at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Drop Chain Earrings
New
$16.99
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Opal Center Pendant Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Opal Center Pendant Necklace
New
$21.99
Celestial Draping Chain Starburst Open Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Celestial Draping Chain Starburst Open Ring
New
$5.99
18K Gold Plated Celestial Sparkle Starburst Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Celestial Sparkle Starburst Necklace
New
$14.99
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Teardrop Pendant Necklace
New
$8.99
Quick buy
Lariat Style Star of Bethlehem Necklace | Gold or Silver
$6.99
Star of Bethlehem starburst bypass ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Starburst Bypass Ring
New
$5.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Cuff Bracelet
$17.99
18K gold plated Star of Bethlehem pendant necklace
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Pendant Necklace
New
$14.99
Gold Star of Bethlehem blue planet rhinestone star drop earrings
Quick buy
Gold Star of Bethlehem Blue Planet Rhinestone Star Drop Earrings
New
$4.99
Gold tone hair clip with three rhinestone eight-point stars
Quick buy
Gold Star of Bethlehem Rhinestone Hair Clip
New
$2.99
Silver Star of Bethlehem etched star top ring
Quick buy
Silver Star of Bethlehem Etched Star Top Ring
New
$5.99
Silver Star of Bethlehem open ring with rhinestone stars at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Open Ring with Rhinestone Stars
New
$4.99
.925 sterling silver plated Star of Bethlehem teardrop pendant necklace
Quick buy
.925 Sterling Silver Plated Star of Bethlehem Teardrop Pendant Necklace
New
$17.99
18K gold plated cubic zirconia Star of Bethlehem rectangle pendant necklace
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Cubic Zirconia Star of Bethlehem Rectangle Pendant Necklace
New
$18.99
Quick buy
Boho Pavé Crystal Star of Bethlehem Pendant Necklace
New
$14.99
Silver Star of Bethlehem three star open ring with rhinestone worn on finger
Quick buy
Silver Star of Bethlehem Three Star Open Ring with Rhinestone
New
$4.99
Gold glittery Star of Bethlehem drop earrings with white beads
Quick buy
Gold Glittery Star of Bethlehem Drop Earrings with White Beads
New
$5.99
.925 sterling silver plated Star of Bethlehem huggie hoop earrings
Quick buy
.925 Sterling Silver Plated Star of Bethlehem Huggie Hoop Earrings
New
$17.95
Gold Star of Bethlehem multi color gem huggie hoop earrings
Quick buy
Gold Star of Bethlehem Multi Color Gem Huggie Hoop Earrings
New
$17.99
18K Gold Plated Starburst Gemstone Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Starburst Gemstone Necklace
New
$21.99
+ 2 more
Quick buy
.925 Sterling Silver Star of Bethlehem Necklace
$17.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Necklace
$12.99
Star of Bethlehem Stud Earrings | 3 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Stud Earrings | 3 Colors
New
From $5.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Sun, Moon & Star Ring
$14.95
Quick buy
Celestial Double Star of Bethlehem Huggie Drop Earrings
New
$5.95
Gold Star of Bethlehem twist drop earrings with cubic zirconia
Quick buy
Gold Star of Bethlehem Twist Drop Earrings with Cubic Zirconia
New
$8.95
18K Gold Plated Triple Star of Bethlehem Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Triple Star of Bethlehem Necklace
New
From $14.95
Star of Bethlehem Double Layer Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Double Layer Necklace
$8.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Sheild Necklace | 2 Styles
$14.95
18K Gold Plated Enamel Starburst Cuff Bracelet at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Enamel Starburst Cuff Bracelet
New
From $17.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Earrings
$17.95
18K gold plated turquoise Star of Bethlehem oval drop earrings
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Turquoise Star of Bethlehem Oval Drop Earrings
New
$14.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated or Solid Sterling Silver Star of Bethlehem Earrings
$17.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Earrings | Gold or Silver
$17.95

Star of Bethlehem jewelry and celestial starburst gifts from The Attic in historic downtown Bethlehem, PA. Necklaces, rings and earrings inspired by the Christmas City star.