Skip to content
Free Shipping over $25 • Open 7 Days • Historic Downtown Bethlehem
Search
Search our store
Log in
Create an account
0
Search
Search our store
New
New Arrivals
Best Sellers
Under $5
Under $10
Mix & Match Deal
Holiday
All Holiday Gifts
Gifts Under $5
Stocking Stuffers Under $10
Holiday Jewelry
Star of Bethlehem Gifts
Holiday Earrings
Holiday Pins
Holiday Socks
18K Gold Gifts
Gift Cards
Vibes
Y2K
Coquette
Boho
Minimalist
Celestial
Goth & Grunge
Evil Eye & Lucky
Cute & Quirky
Retro
Jewelry
18K Gold Plated
Anklets
Bracelets
Earrings
Necklaces
Pins
Rings
Sterling Silver
Accessories
Bag Charms + Keychains
Belts
Cold Weather
Hats + Hair
Scarves + Bandanas
Socks
Sunglasses
Watches
Bags
Backpacks + Belt Bags
Crossbody + Totes
Handbags + Shoulder
Wallets + Wristlets
Women's
Bottoms + Jeans
Dresses + Skirts
Jackets + Outerwear
Shoes
Tops + Shirts
Men's
Bottoms + Jeans
Jackets + Outerwear
Shoes
Tops + Shirts
Consign
Consign FAQ
What We Take
Policies & Procedures
Consignor Login
Store
Apply
Location
Rewards
Gift Cards
New
New Arrivals
Best Sellers
Under $5
Under $10
Mix & Match Deal
Holiday
All Holiday Gifts
Gifts Under $5
Stocking Stuffers Under $10
Holiday Jewelry
Star of Bethlehem Gifts
Holiday Earrings
Holiday Pins
Holiday Socks
18K Gold Gifts
Gift Cards
Vibes
Y2K
Coquette
Boho
Minimalist
Celestial
Goth & Grunge
Evil Eye & Lucky
Cute & Quirky
Retro
Jewelry
18K Gold Plated
Anklets
Bracelets
Earrings
Necklaces
Pins
Rings
Sterling Silver
Accessories
Bag Charms + Keychains
Belts
Cold Weather
Hats + Hair
Scarves + Bandanas
Socks
Sunglasses
Watches
Bags
Backpacks + Belt Bags
Crossbody + Totes
Handbags + Shoulder
Wallets + Wristlets
Women's
Bottoms + Jeans
Dresses + Skirts
Jackets + Outerwear
Shoes
Tops + Shirts
Men's
Bottoms + Jeans
Jackets + Outerwear
Shoes
Tops + Shirts
Consign
Consign FAQ
What We Take
Policies & Procedures
Consignor Login
Store
Apply
Location
Rewards
Gift Cards
More links
Search
Search
Search our store
Log in
Create an account
0
Search
Search our store
Close search
Gifts Under $5
Mix & Match: Buy 3 Save 33%, Buy 5 Half Off
New Arrivals Daily
Home
Right
Holiday Jewelry
Holiday Jewelry
Filter
Sort
Filter by
Clear
Sort by
Best Selling
Sort by
Best Selling
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, new to old
Date, old to new
Apply
Clear all
28 products
Quick buy
.925 Sterling Silver Plated Star of Bethlehem Cuff Bracelet
$17.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Layered Celestial Starburst Pendant Necklace
New
$18.99
Quick buy
Minimalist Celestial Four Point Star Pendant Necklace
New
$6.99
Quick buy
Celestial Draping Chain Starburst Open Ring
New
$5.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Celestial Sparkle Starburst Necklace
New
$14.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Opal Center Pendant Necklace
New
$21.99
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Teardrop Pendant Necklace
New
$8.99
Quick buy
Lariat Style Star of Bethlehem Necklace | Gold or Silver
$6.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Cuff Bracelet
$17.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Pendant Necklace
New
$14.99
Quick buy
Silver Star of Bethlehem Etched Star Top Ring
New
$5.99
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Open Ring with Rhinestone Stars
New
$4.99
Quick buy
.925 Sterling Silver Plated Star of Bethlehem Teardrop Pendant Necklace
New
$17.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Cubic Zirconia Star of Bethlehem Rectangle Pendant Necklace
New
$18.99
Quick buy
Silver Star of Bethlehem Three Star Open Ring with Rhinestone
New
$4.99
Quick buy
.925 Sterling Silver Star of Bethlehem Necklace
$17.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Necklace
$12.99
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Triple Star of Bethlehem Necklace
New
From
$14.95
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Double Layer Necklace
$8.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Sheild Necklace | 2 Styles
$14.95
Quick buy
Stainless Steel Star of Bethlehem Necklace
New
$8.99
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Shooting Star Adjustable Ring
New
$4.99
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Starburst Bypass Ring
New
$5.99
Quick buy
Boho Pavé Crystal Star of Bethlehem Pendant Necklace
New
$14.99
Quick buy
Silver Crystal Snowflake Charm Thin Chain Necklace
New
$6.95
Quick buy
Gold Christmas Tree Outline Pendant Necklace
New
$5.95
Quick buy
Red and White Beaded Christmas Wish Bracelet on Card
New
$4.95
Quick buy
Christmas Silicone Charm Bracelet
New
$0.95
+ 1 more
Holiday necklaces, rings and bracelets.
