Free Shipping over $25   •   Open 7 Days   •   Historic Downtown Bethlehem

Under $5

Filter by
Sort by Date, new to old
Sort by

275 products

Heart & Floral Twilly Scarf at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Blue Satin Twilly Scarf with Person Hugging a Heart Print
New
$4.99
Cone Flower Twilly Scarf at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Mustard & White Coneflower Print Satin Twilly Scarf
New
$3.99
Feathered Peacock Feather Bypass Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Feathered Peacock Feather Bypass Ring
New
$4.99
Whimsical Red Eye Frog Bypass Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Whimsical Red Eye Frog Bypass Ring
New
$4.99
Vintage Inspired Carnelian Style Filigree Oval Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Vintage Inspired Carnelian Style Filigree Oval Ring
New
$4.99
Vintage Fleur De Lis Cross Open Ring | 2 Options at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Vintage Fleur De Lis Cross Open Ring | 2 Options
New
$4.99
Filigree Butterfly Statement Ring | 2 Options at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Filigree Butterfly Statement Ring | 2 Options
New
$4.99
Minimalist Double Band Beaded Wire Adjustable Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Minimalist Double Band Beaded Wire Adjustable Ring
New
$4.99
Star of Bethlehem Shooting Star Adjustable Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Star of Bethlehem Shooting Star Adjustable Ring
New
$4.99
Punk Alt Safety Pin Hair Clip Barrette | 2 Options at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Punk Alt Safety Pin Hair Clip Barrette | 2 Options
New
$1.99
Minimalist Chain Link Open Band Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Minimalist Chain Link Open Band Ring
New
$4.99
Gothic Four Leaf Clover Beaded Eternity Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Gothic Four Leaf Clover Beaded Eternity Ring
New
$4.99
Vintage Style Gothic Marquise Black Gem Beaded Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Vintage Style Gothic Marquise Black Gem Beaded Ring
New
$4.99
Vintage Style Gothic Emerald Cut Purple Gem Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Vintage Style Gothic Emerald Cut Purple Gem Ring
New
$4.99
Gold bumblebee keychain with pearl, daisy and honey charms
Quick buy
Butterfly and Flower Charm Keychain Bag Charm
New
$3.99
Silver cat and fish charm keychain
Quick buy
Silver Cat & Fish Charm Keychain
New
$3.99
Gold bow outline earrings with faux pearl tails
Quick buy
Gold Bow Outline Earrings with Faux Pearl Tails
New
$4.99
Silver Red and White Popcorn Bucket Earrings
Quick buy
Silver Red and White Popcorn Bucket Earrings
New
$4.99
Gold Angel Charm Keychain with Faux Pearl at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Gold Angel Charm Keychain with Faux Pearl
New
$4.99
The Black Cat Society round enamel pin with black cats
Quick buy
The Black Cat Society Round Enamel Pin
New
$4.99
Western Cowboy Hat Dangle Earrings | 2 Options at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Western Cowboy Hat Dangle Earrings | 2 Options
New
$4.99
Y2K Glitter Star Snap Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Viral Y2K Glitter Star Snap Hair Clip | 3 Options
New
$1.99
Y2K Polka Dot Star Snap Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Viral Y2K Polka Dot Star Snap Hair Clip | 6 Options
New
$1.99
+ 3 more
Silver mini adjustable wrench keychain
Quick buy
Silver Mini Wrench Keychain
New
$3.99
Y2K Star Snap Hair Clips at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Viral Y2K Star Snap Hair Clips | 23 Options
New
$1.99
+ 19 more
Green turtle and fish friend keychain with silver ring
Quick buy
Green Turtle and Fish Friend Keychain with Silver Ring
New
$3.99
Yellow rubber chicken squeeze keychain with silver ring
Quick buy
Yellow Rubber Chicken Squeeze Keychain with Silver Ring
New
$4.99
Vintage Style Purple Gem Gold Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Vintage Style Purple Gem Gold Ring | 4 Options
New
$4.99
+ 1 more
Multi-Row C-Shape Hoop Earrings | Gold or Silver at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Multi-Row C-Shape Hoop Earrings | Gold or Silver
New
$4.99
Flocked Velvet Bow Stud Earrings at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Flocked Velvet Bow Stud Earrings
New
$4.99
Silver Rhinestone Bunny Stud Earrings at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Silver Rhinestone Bunny Stud Earrings
New
$4.99
Quick buy
Kawaii Ocean Plush Animal Bag Charm
New
$3.99
+ 1 more
Quick buy
Silver Rainbow Cloud Pride Dangle Earrings
New
$4.99
Black rhinestone open star snap hair clip
Quick buy
Black Rhinestone Star Snap Hair Clip
New
$2.99
Rhinestone Cherry Stud Earrings | Red or Clear at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Rhinestone Cherry Stud Earrings | Red or Clear
New
$4.99
Silver twisted rope chain bracelet
Quick buy
Silver Twisted Rope Chain Bracelet
New
$4.99
Gold Star of Bethlehem blue planet rhinestone star drop earrings
Quick buy
Gold Star of Bethlehem Blue Planet Rhinestone Star Drop Earrings
New
$4.99
Black square Be A Nice Human enamel pin with silver tone edge
Quick buy
Black Be A Nice Human Square Enamel Pin
New
$4.99
Silver butterfly keychain with daisy and bee charms
Quick buy
Silver Butterfly Keychain with Daisy & Bee Charms
New
$3.99
Cream Crew Socks with Embroidered Dog | 3 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Cream Crew Socks with Embroidered Dog | 3 Styles
New
$4.99
Ribbed Mid Calf Socks with Embroidered Bow | Cream or Lilac at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Ribbed Mid Calf Socks with Embroidered Bow | Cream or Lilac
New
$4.99
Quick buy
Vintage Fair Isle Scottie Dog Knit Crew Socks | 3 Colors
New
$4.99
Quick buy
Polka Dot Ruffle Cuff Knit Crew Socks | 5 Colors
New
$4.99
+ 2 more
Classic Dainty Sequined Chain Anklet | 1 Option at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Classic Dainty Sequined Chain Anklet | 1 Option
New
$4.99
Silver snake chain anklet worn
Quick buy
Silver Simple Snake Chain Anklet
New
$4.99
Treble Clef Music Note Hair Barrette at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Treble Clef Music Note Hair Barrette
New
$1.99
+ 2 more
Novelty Dental Care Hair Clip | 3 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Novelty Dental Care Hair Clip | 3 Styles
New
$1.99
Five Petal Flower Claw Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Five Petal Flower Claw Hair Clip
New
$3.99

Trendy new jewelry, hair clips and charms for $5 or less. Mix & Match: buy 3 save 33%, buy 5 half off.