Free Shipping over $25   •   Open 7 Days   •   Historic Downtown Bethlehem

Under $5

Filter by
Sort by Date, new to old
Sort by

275 products

Quick buy
Black Heart Hair Clip
New
$2.95
Quick buy
Attic Virgo Pin
New
$4.95
Women Belong in the Lab Feminist Science Enamel Pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Women Belong in the Lab Feminist Science Enamel Pin
New
$4.95
Enamel pin of a green frog playing guitar on an orange spotted mushroom
Quick buy
Frog Playing Guitar on Orange Mushroom Enamel Pin
New
$4.95
Round enamel pin with a green eye and the words Black Like My Heart
Quick buy
Black Like My Heart Green Eye Enamel Pin
New
$4.95
Three Hearts Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Three Hearts Hair Clip
New
$2.95
+ 1 more
Christmas Felt Dangle Earrings at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Christmas Felt Dangle Earrings
New
$4.95
+ 2 more
Christmas silicone charm bracelet with tree charm
Quick buy
Christmas Silicone Charm Bracelet
New
$0.95
+ 1 more
Dainty Silver Tone Blue Evil Eye Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Dainty Silver Tone Blue Evil Eye Necklace
New
$4.95
Gold Tone Dual Color Enamel Adjustable Ring | Blue or Emerald at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Gold Tone Dual Color Enamel Adjustable Ring | Blue or Emerald
New
$4.95
Gold Tone White Enamel Ring | 2 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Gold Tone White Enamel Ring | 2 Styles
New
From $4.95
Gold Multi-Color Enamel Open Band Ring
Quick buy
Gold Multi-Color Enamel Open Band Ring
New
$4.95
Silver Glam Butterfly Ring
Quick buy
Silver Glam Butterfly Ring
New
$4.95
Silver Angled Butterfly Pendant Necklace
Quick buy
Silver Angled Butterfly Pendant Necklace
New
$4.95
Silver Rhinestone Butterfly Pendant Necklace
Quick buy
Silver Rhinestone Butterfly Pendant Necklace
New
$4.95
Wide Plastic Hoop Earrings | 7 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Wide Plastic Hoop Earrings | 7 Colors
New
From $4.95
+ 4 more
Silver Tone Whimsical Punk Ring | 3 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Silver Tone Whimsical Punk Ring | 3 Styles
New
$4.95
Silver Orange Mini Hamburger Dangle Earrings
Quick buy
Silver Orange Mini Hamburger Dangle Earrings
New
$4.95
Silver Yellow Pizza Slice Dangle Earrings
Quick buy
Silver Yellow Pizza Slice Dangle Earrings
New
$4.95
See Through Butterfly Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
See Through Butterfly Hair Clip
New
$2.95
+ 1 more
Zodiac constellation enamel pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Zodiac Constellation Enamel Pin
New
$4.95
+ 8 more
Dainty Gold Tone Evil Eye Pendant Necklace | 3 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Dainty Gold Tone Evil Eye Pendant Necklace | 3 Colors
New
$4.95
Silver Skeleton Hands Heart Ring
Quick buy
Silver Skeleton Hands Heart Ring
New
$4.95
Beaded Daisy Flower Stretch Bracelet | 7 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Beaded Daisy Flower Stretch Bracelet | 7 Colors
New
From $4.95
+ 4 more
Black Cord Yellow Sunflower Adjustable Bracelet
Quick buy
Black Cord Yellow Sunflower Adjustable Bracelet
New
$3.99
Silver Butterfly Micro Inlay Open Double Band Ring
Quick buy
Silver Butterfly Micro Inlay Open Double Band Ring
New
$4.95
Silver Simple Double Butterfly Open Ring
Quick buy
Silver Simple Double Butterfly Open Ring
New
$4.50
Celestial Sun Moon Asymmetrical Huggie Earrings | 3 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Celestial Sun Moon Asymmetrical Huggie Earrings | 3 Colors
New
From $4.95
Rubber Duck Dangle Earrings | 5 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Rubber Duck Dangle Earrings | 5 Colors
New
From $4.95
+ 2 more
Novelty Frog Dangle Earrings | Green or Pink at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Novelty Frog Dangle Earrings | Green or Pink
New
From $4.95
Silver White Puffy Cloud Dangle Earrings
Quick buy
Silver White Puffy Cloud Dangle Earrings
New
$4.95
Star and Moon Lariat Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Star and Moon Lariat Necklace | Gold or Silver
New
From $4.95
Dainty Butterfly Small Hoop Earrings at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Dainty Butterfly Small Hoop Earrings | Gold or Silver
New
$3.95
Open Knot Heart Adjustable Ring Minimalist Fashion Jewelry | 3 Options at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Open Knot Heart Adjustable Ring Minimalist Fashion Jewelry | 3 Options
New
$4.95
Thick Chain Link Necklace at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Thick Chain Link Necklace | Gold or Silver
New
From $4.95

Trendy new jewelry, hair clips and charms for $5 or less. Mix & Match: buy 3 save 33%, buy 5 half off.