Free Shipping over $25   •   Open 7 Days   •   Historic Downtown Bethlehem

Best Sellers

Filter by
Sort by Best Selling
Sort by

1476 products

Silver Orange Mini Hamburger Dangle Earrings
Quick buy
Silver Orange Mini Hamburger Dangle Earrings
New
$4.95
Silver Yellow Pizza Slice Dangle Earrings
Quick buy
Silver Yellow Pizza Slice Dangle Earrings
New
$4.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Bling Ring
$17.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Blue Cubic Zirconia Ring
$14.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Curve Ring
$21.95
Quick buy
Cupcake Icing Decoration Hair Clip | 4 Styles
From $1.95
+ 1 more
Love is Love Pride Bead Bracelet Set of 2 | 2 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Love is Love Pride Bead Bracelet Set of 2 | 2 Styles
New
$5.95
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated or Solid Sterling Silver Star of Bethlehem Earrings
$17.95
Quick buy
Comb Hair Clip | Silver or Gold
$2.95
See Through Butterfly Hair Clip at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
See Through Butterfly Hair Clip
New
$2.95
+ 1 more
Zodiac constellation enamel pin at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Zodiac Constellation Enamel Pin
New
$4.95
+ 8 more
Quick buy
Coffee Cat Pin
$4.95
Dainty Gold Tone Evil Eye Pendant Necklace | 3 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Dainty Gold Tone Evil Eye Pendant Necklace | 3 Colors
New
$4.95
Vintage Owl Eyes Adjustable Ring | 6 Colors at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Vintage Owl Eyes Adjustable Ring | 6 Colors
New
$5.95
+ 3 more
Quick buy
18K Gold Plated Star of Bethlehem Earrings | Gold or Silver
$17.95
Rhinestone Crescent Moon Open Ring at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Rhinestone Crescent Moon Open Ring | 3 Colors
New
From $5.95
Quick buy
Pride Love Pride Pin
$3.95
Angel Number Necklace in Gold | 10 Options! at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Angel Number Necklace in Gold | 10 Options!
$6.95
+ 7 more
Silver Tone Angel Number Pendant Necklace | 10 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Silver Tone Angel Number Pendant Necklace | 10 Styles
New
$6.95
+ 7 more
Quick buy
Toy Dinosaur Earrings | Wear Your Favorite!
From $6.95
+ 5 more
Zodiac Gemstone Adjustable Rope Bracelet | 12 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Zodiac Gemstone Adjustable Rope Bracelet | 12 Styles
New
$5.95
+ 9 more
Silver Skeleton Hands Heart Ring
Quick buy
Silver Skeleton Hands Heart Ring
New
$4.95
Quick buy
Stainless Steel Star of Bethlehem Necklace
New
$8.99
Quick buy
Zodiac Red Rope Bracelet
$4.95
+ 9 more
Black Cord Yellow Sunflower Adjustable Bracelet
Quick buy
Black Cord Yellow Sunflower Adjustable Bracelet
New
$3.99
Silver Butterfly Micro Inlay Open Double Band Ring
Quick buy
Silver Butterfly Micro Inlay Open Double Band Ring
New
$4.95
Silver Simple Double Butterfly Open Ring
Quick buy
Silver Simple Double Butterfly Open Ring
New
$4.50
Silver Zodiac Symbol Necklace | 12 Signs! at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Silver Zodiac Symbol Necklace | 12 Signs!
$6.95
+ 9 more
Gold Tone Zodiac Symbol Pendant Necklace on Card | 12 Styles at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Gold Tone Zodiac Symbol Pendant Necklace on Card | 12 Styles
New
$6.95
+ 9 more
Novelty Frog Dangle Earrings | Green or Pink at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Novelty Frog Dangle Earrings | Green or Pink
New
From $4.95
Quick buy
Gold Lightning Bolt Necklace
$4.95
Silver White Puffy Cloud Dangle Earrings
Quick buy
Silver White Puffy Cloud Dangle Earrings
New
$4.95
Multi-Color Smiley Face Rice Bead Necklace
Quick buy
Multi-Color Smiley Face Rice Bead Necklace
New
$5.95
Quick buy
Sun Pendant Necklace | Gold or Silver
$5.95
Dainty Butterfly Small Hoop Earrings at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Dainty Butterfly Small Hoop Earrings | Gold or Silver
New
$3.95
Open Knot Heart Adjustable Ring Minimalist Fashion Jewelry | 3 Options at The Attic Bethlehem
Quick buy
Open Knot Heart Adjustable Ring Minimalist Fashion Jewelry | 3 Options
New
$4.95

Our most popular jewelry and accessories.